Penguins Thoughts: Prepare for Karlsson; Pens’ Trade Chips


ln an increasingly rare dateline, this comes from the home rink, and the Pittsburgh Penguins battle not only against the quality teams they are battling for a playoff spot but, like an old Polaroid of happier times, to finally recapture the best version of themselves.

With each passing day and each gut-punch loss, the Penguins get further from their goals and their potential.

It wasn’t supposed to be like this.

The summer excitement almost bordered on jubilation when the Penguins and president of hockey operations/GM Kyle Dubas pulled off a heist for defenseman Karlsson. In the process, Dubas traded Petry, Mikael Granlund, and Jan Rutta, none of whom distinguished themselves in their time with the Penguins.

The number of games is getting smaller, and the number of wins needed is getting bigger.

No, it wasn’t supposed to be like this, but that matters no more than the iconic character Dante Hicks exclaiming for three movies, “I’m not even supposed to be here today.”

The Penguins have five games in hand on the Flyers but trail them by 11 points, meaning they must win all five to be close to leapfrogging into a playoff spot.

Editor’s note: The original version listed the Penguins as nine points behind Philadelphia.

The Penguins trail the Detroit Red Wings by seven points with only three games in hand. Even if the Penguins win all three, they’re still short of both Detroit and the Toronto Maple Leafs, whom they trail by nine points.

Oh by the way, the New Jersey Devils have won two in a row and got Jack Hughes back from the injured list. New Jersey is ahead of the Penguins in the standings, too.

All of the teams in a playoff spot have won at least five of their last 10. The Penguins and the chasers have won no more than four.

Penguins Want-To?

My first thought is this team doesn’t have enough drive or desire to get there. They would have shown it already. It is inexplicable that for two seasons, they’ve talked about needing to be consistent. They’ve talked about bringing their best and the frustration after they don’t.

But the same record is still playing; need and regret aren’t good songs to put on repeat.

If Dubas is serious about getting this team into the playoffs, he doesn’t need blockbusters, but he needs a change in team construction and chemistry.

2. Erik Karlsson is done trying to fit in and ready to take over.

It has long seemed like Karlsson was trying to fit himself into the Penguins system rather than fit the system to Karlsson, and the results have been below expectations.

He’s ready to take the puck and lead.

That’s just my gut reaction watching him start to take over in Minnesota, then absolutely take the puck with impunity in Winnipeg. I think we’re about to see Karlsson go off, and that’s not a bad thing.

There are only three defensemen in the league, including Karlsson, who can play an offensive game like he does. The other two are Cale Makar and Quinn Hughes.

Would the Penguins be so bad with a Crosby – Erik Karlsson core? Could Dubas remake the Penguins on that bedrock, now or in the summer?

3. Not All is What it Seems

The criticisms of Rickard Rakell and Bryan Rust are both valid and ignore possible extenuating circumstances. You’ll notice neither have been able to produce and don’t look like themselves since they returned from upper body injuries. Rakell had a small spurt of offense before buying another ticket for the struggle bus. Rust hasn’t been himself with the puck, though his desire and competition level are still obvious.

Player intel is closely guarded, so don’t expect an expose, but you won’t see me criticizing them, either. It’s impossible to fathom that Rust is struggling due to a lack of effort.

Rust’s and Rakell’s struggles will put pressure squarely on Smith and a little on Jesse Puljujarvi. Smith is a scoring winger who’s not scoring, but like Karlsson, Smith played his best game in some time during the 2-1 loss to the Winnipeg Jets last Saturday.

Maybe he, too, will let rip.

4. The Penguins’ Trade Chips/Deadline

The distance between the Penguins and the playoff line in the standings is both a mirage and a problem. Their games in hand on everyone is an opportunity, but asking them to win all five, or even all three, seems unrealistic.

Coach Mike Sullivan punted when PHN asked Wednesday morning if we’re getting into the “must” win territory. But the reality is they are. With every loss, they slip farther back.

Realize that they’re not racing against the end of the regular season but against the NHL trade deadline on March 8. If they’re realistically six points back, then it’s probably time to sell.

That would mean trading Jake Guentzel.

And it should mean putting a goalie on the trade block, too. Alex Nedeljkovic could quickly become a hot commodity for New Jersey or Edmonton, who don’t want to pony up the pebbles for Juuse Saros, John Gibson, or Jacob Markstrom.

could be a comfy mid-size acquisition that brings a healthy return because of his stellar play and his relatively minuscule salary ($1.5 million). It might not be out of the question to ask for a first-rounder because of the tight market and ease in fitting the salary, but a second-rounder with a little sweetener is more likely.

Related Posts

Foreshadowing Trades? Penguins Move O’Connor to Center, Suffers Concussion

Pittsburgh Penguins coach Mike Sullivan made several changes to his lines Tuesday, in what could have been foreshadowing the Penguins’ lineup following the NHL trade deadline on Friday. After three straight bruising losses on the recent four-game road trip and deflated spirits, Sullivan made a couple of surprising moves, including moving Drew O’Connor to third-line […]

Minor Penguins Trade; Hellberg Dealt to Contender

Magnus Hellberg’s time with the Pittsburgh Penguins and the organization came to a close Friday afternoon just before the 3 p.m. NHL trade deadline. The Penguins traded Hellburg to the Panthers. The Penguins received little compensation: a conditional seventh-round pick and 27-year-old Swiss goalie Ludovic Waeber, who is playing in his first North American pro […]

Penguins Grades: Young Legs & Goaltending Shine, Pens Capable of ‘Better’

The Pittsburgh Penguins scored a power-play goal as the front end of two goals in 21 seconds. The outburst erased an otherwise ordinary, bordering on lackluster Penguins performance as they beat the Montreal Canadiens 4-1 at PPG Paints Arena. The Penguins also got some playoff help as the New York Rangers beat the New Jersey […]

Penguins Place Rust on IR, Make Roster Call-Up

SEATTLE — The Pittsburgh Penguins made the unsurprising move of placing right-winger Bryan Rust on injured reserve. The team also recalled forward Jonathan Gruden from the Wilkes-Barre/Scranton Penguins. Gurden, 23, has played five NHL games this season and eight in his career. He has yet to register his first point. In 41 AHL games this […]

My Mourning Jackets: Penguins Hold Off Columbus, 5-3

The Pittsburgh Penguins have whittled their magic number to 29. Not to clinch, say, a division championship or home-ice advantage for the opening round of the Stanley Cup playoffs, but to avoid finishing last in the Metropolitan Division. OK, so that’s not much of a feat for a franchise with five Stanley Cup banners hanging […]

WATCH: Guentzel, Penguins Trade Analysis

The Pittsburgh Penguins made their move. On the eve of the NHL trade deadline, Penguins president of hockey operations/GM Kyle Dubas traded Jake Guentzel to the Carolina Hurricanes for five assets, including NHL winger Michael Bunting. However, the analysis gets rough. Pittsburgh Hockey Now’s Dan Kingerski details the Penguins’ haul for Guentzel, including the three […]

Capitals Punishment: Washington Embarrasses Penguins, 6-0

The Pittsburgh Penguins didn’t hold any players out of their game against Washington Thursday night at PPG Paints Arena for “trade-related reasons,” as a number of clubs have done lately. That doesn’t mean that everyone in their lineup actually was involved in the game, though. Truth be told, there have been cruise ships with fewer […]

ESPN Reports Penguins ‘Sky High’ Asking Price on Guentzel

The Pittsburgh Penguins control their playoff fate with games in hand and being close enough to the teams they’re chasing that if those games in hand are converted to wins, the Penguins would be in a playoff spot. Yet the NHL trade rumors continue to swirl around injured left winger Jake Guentzel. Tuesday, ESPN’s Emily […]